|

click for help
collapse
On this page press one of the expand
buttons to see the full text of an article. Later
press collapse to revert to the original
form. The button below expands all articles.
show all
More recent news
Children Protected from Protector
March 13, 2007
Another one of those angels who protect your children has
been arrested, this time for abusing her own children. She
was not a lowly caseworker, but a senior officer. This is
likely to be one of those stories we never hear about
again.
expand
collapse
Atlanta Journal-Constitution
DFCS official denies abuse
By CRAIG SCHNEIDER, Published on: 03/13/07
One of Fulton County's top child welfare officials was
arrested after being accused of striking her 8-year-old
daughter 34 times with a belt, police said Monday.
Cylenthia Clark, 38, of Fayetteville was charged with
felony child cruelty on Saturday. Clark is assistant
director of the Fulton County office of the state Division
of Family and Children Services.
Cylenthia Clark's four daughters have been placed in
protective custody. She is out on bond.
|
The arrest warrant alleges that on
Feb. 7, Clark told the child to remove all her clothes
except her panties and then whipped her with the belt on
the back, arms, legs and face.
The girl and her three sisters, ages 6, 5 and 3, were
taken from Clark's care and placed in protective custody,
Fayetteville police Lt. Beverly Trainor said.
In an interview, Clark acknowledged spanking her
daughter but said, "I am not a child abuser. I have never
abused my children." Clark got out of jail on bond
Saturday.
Trainor said the girl's school reported marks on the
child's back and arms Feb. 28 to Fayette DFCS. That
report was passed on to Fayetteville police.
Clark said her daughter had been aggressive lately,
fighting in an after-school program at Hood Avenue Primary
and even fighting a teacher who tried to break it up.
"I did spank her, but I didn't abuse her," Clark said.
"I don't even want to spank my kids, but it's a last
resort."
DFCS spokeswoman Dena Smith said Clark is back on the
job but only doing administrative work and has no
involvement in child protection cases.
The arrest of one of Fulton's top child welfare
officials stunned workers in the county office and leaders
in Georgia's child welfare community. Officials at Fulton
DFCS have power to investigate parents for child abuse and
neglect, and even to remove children from their homes and
place them in foster care.
"We would hope that the people we entrust with our
children would hold the same values as we do," said Normer
Adams, executive director of the Georgia Association of
Homes and Services for Children. "The values that people
hold reflect in what they practice. How can you take
someone's child away, when you're doing something like
this?"
Adams said he thinks Clark should be put on
administrative leave until the case is resolved.
DFCS officials said Clark arrived in the Fulton office
less than a year ago. Clark and her husband are
separated, Fayetteville police said, and he lives in
another state.
Fulton DFCS workers said the office was shocked to hear
the news. "She's a nice person," said Fulton DFCS worker
Richard Maynard. "It's unfortunate, and my prayers go out
to her and her family."
Shantreas O'Neil, a Fulton social services specialist,
said, "All of us doing this work are responsible for
protecting the kids, so it would surprise me if this
happened to any worker."
Neighbors at Weatherly Walk apartments in Fayetteville
said Clark appeared to be a caring mother.
"I was always amazed she could get all those little
girls dressed and herself ready for work," said Lori Holt,
the mother of twin 8-month-old boys. "I'm doing good to
get out of here with bottles and diapers."
Clark said she was surprised to be arrested.
"I'm sure they [Fayette DFCS and police] were following
protocol, but from my experience that [an arrest] is
reserved for more severe cases," Clark said.
The arrest comes as Fulton DFCS has come under attack
from several of its own workers who criticized top
managers as arrogant and belligerent. The workers say the
management style has prompted many employees to leave,
burdening others with more work and leaving some children
in danger of abuse and neglect.
State DFCS Director Mary Dean Harvey said the Fulton
office has increased its scrutiny of workers since a
lawsuit settlement last year in which a federal court
ordered the office to improve its care of children.
She said the greater demands may have led some
disgruntled workers to complain and leave. She also said
the Fulton office is performing better.
Staff writers Kathy Jefcoats and S.A. Reid contributed
to this article.
Addendum: Social workers are in
the habit of destroying families with false allegations, and
when they want to purge one of their own, they do it the
same way. This could be a case of social worker
fratricide.
Addendum: This later article
shows that the mother in this case got preferential
treatment.
expand
collapse
Atlanta Journal-Constitution
DFCS workers felt pressured to play
favorites, advocate says
By Craig Schneider, Kathy Jefcoats
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Published on: 04/12/07
Fayette County child welfare workers felt pressure from
their state office to close the case against a top
employee charged with beating her daughter, the state
child advocate said Wednesday.
Child Advocate Dee Simms said Gov. Sonny Perdue
personally requested she find out if favoritism was shown
to Cylenthia Clark, deputy director of the Fulton County
child welfare office.
Clark was charged with felony child cruelty March 10
after Fayette school officials reported marks on the
child's back and arms to the Fayette office of the state
Division of Family and Children Services. Fayetteville
police said that on Feb. 7, Clark ordered her 8-year-old
daughter to remove her clothes and whipped her 34 times
with a belt.
DFCS officials said the case was handled properly and
that Clark was not given preferential treatment. Clark,
who has been reassigned to administrative duties at the
Fulton DFCS office, could not be reached Wednesday for
comment. A month ago, she said she spanked her daughter,
but didn't abuse her.
Simms said her investigators interviewed several
workers in the Fayette office of DFCS. "It is my feeling
that they felt pressure to minimize it [the case] or make
it go away," Simms said. She said she hasn't gotten state
DFCS's side of the story yet.
Police placed the girl and her three sisters in foster
care, but DFCS quickly moved the children into the home of
their maternal grandmother, Simms said.
One Fayette caseworker wrote the governor to complain
about the way the case was handled. Tracy Murray said the
state office "mandated" that her office waive the drug
screen and criminal background check in order to quickly
place the children with the grandmother.
"Governor, make no mistake the leadership representing
this department is in full support of this mother who has
beaten her child with no remorse," Murray wrote.
State DFCS Director Mary Dean Harvey said she often
reviews individual county cases and, working in
consultation with the county, discusses waivers on
background checks.
The children have since been placed in the custody of
their father, who lives in Chicago, authorities said.
State Department of Human Resources officials say
they're conducting an internal investigation. "We haven't
found anything to show that DFCS has done anything wrong,"
said Cathy Lynn, deputy director of the state Office of
Investigative Services, an arm of DHR. DFCS is also an
arm of DHR.
The difference of opinion sets up yet another conflict
between state DFCS, the agency tasked with handling child
welfare services, and the child advocate, appointed to
keep watch over DFCS. Simms recently issued a blistering
report on the Fulton DFCS office.
Fayette District Attorney Scott Ballard also has
started an investigation into whether Fayette DFCS delayed
reporting the abuse allegations to Fayetteville police.
Harvey said DFCS notified police by fax shortly after
receiving the abuse allegation from the girl's teacher.
Ballard said he needs to confirm that, but said DFCS
did not follow protocol and telephone police to confirm.
Consequently, he said, police did not begin the
investigation for another 20 days.
Group Home Embezzles Kid's Pay
March 12, 2007
A blog by a resident of Kennedy House in
Scarborough Ontario recounts his experiences under the
screen name Ed Blazo, really his nemesis at the group home.
Among other experiences, he recounts the rape of a fellow
resident. Below is his story of how part of his pay from a
summer job was embezzled by the group home staff.
expand
collapse
Ed Blazo
|
I am in grade 12 and exams are just around the corner.
The stress of living in this hostile house is weighing
down on me. I think I have been through a lot in this
four and half years that I called this house home.
Instead of building young boys into confident responsible
men, the goal seems to be how to beat the soul and spirit
out of these young bucks. How many guys that have gone
through Kennedy house's doors have made it. Ok, make it
easier, how many have stayed out of jail? Not many.
Still the world revolves around money, so Ed was not going
to be pulling in any more money from the children's aid
for anyone who is over 18, so out they go. And to make
sure they are out and he doesn't have to carry them, he
gives ya the boot before your 18th birthday. So like I
said with exams around the corner, I was told to look for
an apartment. I said how was I to pay the rent? Kathy
said that I would be given student welfare till I finished
grade 12. I said what about after that? She said as far
as going on to further my education, she didn't see that
as an option. Best that once I finished school to look
for a job. Immediately. I asked about the 25% of my pay
she has socked away. When do I receive that? She said:
sorry, but that money went back into the house. But I
said that when we were told to give her 25% of our pay
when we were forced to work the summer and also whenever I
worked — hell they even took Tyrone's 25% when he
slaved all day selling Dicky Dee ice cream — it
would be returned to us upon leaving the house, so(rt) of
like a hope chest — funds to sock away for a rainy
day. She went into: do you know how much it costs to
keep me here? She said that I would find out once I was
on my own.
Endless Accusations
March 11, 2007
James Nord, an Arizona man in a business where he could
make enemies, is anonymously accused of molesting a
ten-year-old boy living in his home. When child protectors
find the man lives alone, the accusation changes to
molesting at the home of the boy's mother. When they can't
find her, he is accused of molesting his own sister and son.
The caseworker tells the man his file has been closed, but
continues to question his friends. He is on a list of
low-risk sexual predators, but cannot find the name of his
accuser. The caseworker continues because she collects a
bounty for her investigation. Child protection is too
important to stop for mere innocence, or even absurdity.
expand
collapse
Sunday, March 11, 2007
Man upset over probe for alleged child
molestation
Suzanne Cronn-Herald/Review
James Nord reviews a document in his home office on
Sunday. Nord has file a $50 million dollar law suit
against Cochise County and the state stemming from an
accusation of child molestation of which no evidence
was found and the case was closed.
|
By Shar Porier
Herald/Review
SIERRA VISTA — “They don’t care who they screw
up.”
The frustration of 66-year-old paralegal James Nord
over an alleged incident of child molestation, which he
claims landed his name in a file at Child Protective
Services as a “low risk” sexual predator, continues as
he tries to clear his name.
It all started more than a year ago on Feb. 28 when he
got a call from CPS investigator Marilyn Piduch at his
home in Sierra Vista. She asked if she could meet with
him. He agreed, and Piduch and Marde Closson, local CPS
supervisor, came to his home and told him a complaint had
been filed. They had been told a woman and her
10-year-old son were living with him, and that he had
molested the boy. After an inspection of his home, they
found no evidence of anyone living with Nord.
“I’ve lived alone for 18 years, with the exception
of my son and his family when they first moved here,” he
said.
Wondering who could have made such an accusation, he
asked for the name of his accuser and was told the
identity could not be revealed.
He filed a complaint with the Cochise County’s
Sheriff’s Office for false reporting and harassment
against the CPS.
Deputy Cpl. John Filippelli took the complaint and
called CPS in an attempt to confirm a name given by Nord
as the possible informant. The deputy states in a report
that CPS told him the caller wished to remain anonymous
but that it was definitely not the person suspected. He
then went to Nord’s residence and advised him of the
findings.
“Nord advised when CPS completes their investigation
he will file a petition to disclose the name of the person
reporting. I advised Nord if/when he finds out the
subject’s name to contact me, and I will continue the
investigation,” he writes in the report.
Though Nord said Filippelli met with him the morning of
March 2 and told him CPS had closed the case, there is no
such statement in the deputy’s official report.
Filippelli’s investigation is listed as active/dead file
pending further information from Nord on the identity of
the person who called CPS with the complaint.
Part of Nord’s complaint of CPS’ actions involves
the continuing investigation involving friends and family
after the case had supposedly been closed.
Piduch interviewed Nord’s son, Carl, on the same day
and questioned him about the woman and her son.
Nothing further was done until May 17, when Nord
requested a copy of the complaint. On June 8, he received
the CPS summary report, which gave a different scenario.
In the report, Nord was accused of molesting the
10-year-old daughter of a woman while living with her at
her residence. The report also states he violently
molested and assaulted his sister for four years and
molested his son.
Nord and his son were upset over the new allegations
listed in the summary report.
“I don’t understand. First it was a boy. Now
it’s a girl, my sister and my son. It’s absurd,”
Nord said.
Carl Nord says there wasn’t an incident involving
him.
“Nothing ever happened to me or my aunt. I
checked,” he said. “There are no people living with
Dad or he with them. It’s a crock. Somebody’s made
up the complaint. They investigated and found no
evidence, but, yet, they continued. If the case was
opened and closed on the same day, as they said, why did
they call me in March?”
Nord decided he was going to get to the bottom of it
and tried to get a judge to allow the identity of his
accuser to be revealed and his name cleared. The case
went before Cochise County Superior Court Judge James L.
Conlogue.
Assistant Attorney General Roger Perry Jr. argued
against releasing the name. According to documentation on
file at the courthouse concerning the case, Perry stated,
“There can be no justification for a request that all
records concerning the petitioner be expunged from CPS
files,” he said, “Arizona maintains a record of the
report as it must, according to law.”
Conlogue ruled against Nord’s request and ordered the
file sealed.
Nord suspects he was the subject of retribution of
someone, but he hasn’t a clue who that may be.
His friend Betty Madrid believes she knows who filed
the complaint. Nord was helping her on a legal matter
involving fraud. According to her affidavit, Madrid
called Piduch on March 1 and said she “was positive that
the report was made for vindictive reasons. I told her
that because of my accusation, I was being followed …
She asked me who I thought would do this.”
Madrid gave four names, but was interrupted by Piduch,
who asked how Madrid knew of one of the people mentioned.
That made Madrid suspicious, and she told Nord of the
conversation.
In December, Nord filed a lawsuit against the county,
the state and all the agencies and people involved in
December. His lawsuit claims that Closson and Piduch
“… acted with reckless disregard” and failed to
determine whether probable cause existed before taking
action. He claims violation of his civil rights to due
process, loss of reputation and infliction of emotional
distress among other charges.
He is seeking $50 million in his suit.
“I suffer from headaches, nausea and nervousness.
This whole thing has distracted me from being able to my
job. It interferes with my work,” he says in the court
paperwork.
“One’s reputation is a significant, intensely
personal possession that one strives to protect,” Nord
continued. “The CPS takes everything some mystery party
says as factual and does not need any corroboration of any
sort. They closed the case without any substantiation and
put my name in their files.”
He sought help from an Arizona ombudsman, Ellen
Stenson, who wrote in a letter the case was closed “as
neither substantiated nor unsubstantiated, but rather
noted they were unable to locate (the woman and her
child).
“We do not have any evidence that the CPS
investigation was inappropriate or that CPS has
inappropriately shared information about you …,”
Stenson said in her response.
Stenson’s findings seem to bolster the stand of the
Attorney General’s Office, which is handling the federal
lawsuit.
The state, on behalf of all the agencies and parties
listed in Nord’s suit, is represented by Assistant
Attorney General Perry, who has entered a motion to
dismiss on the grounds that Nord has a “lack of
cognizable legal theory” and “the absence of
sufficient facts.” He states in the motion that CPS, as
an agency of the state, is immune from private damages or
injunctive relief.
As for Nord’s worry of being classified as a sexual
predator in a central registry, Perry says this “is an
example of an unwarranted deduction of fact. (Nord) was
investigated by the CPS; therefore, he reasons, he has
been placed on such a list … it appears (from the
complaint) this claim was not substantiated. There was no
child living in his home to be concerned about. He is not
a convicted sex-offender, subject to registration.”
Perry writes that CPS is required to maintain a record
of the report, but this record in no sense is considered a
predator list. Therefore, Nord’s deduction that since
he was investigated his name exists on a CPS list is
unrealistic.
He states in a court document, “… Criminal
investigations — even if CPS conducted criminal
investigations — can be conducted on no more than a
hunch; they can be conducted on a whim …”
Due to the serious nature of the information included
in the CPS summary report, the agency had the right to
investigate the tip, he argues in the court document.
Perry has tried to have that CPS summary report
rejected as evidence. In a phone conversation, Perry said
Nord had not authenticated the CPS report. Therefore, it
should be disallowed, as should the affidavits Nord
gathered.
“I am asking the court to look at facts alleged in
the complaint. Nord does not state a cause of action
against these people. I have moved to strike things that
are not properly brought before the court,” Perry said.
“I cannot find a cause that would allow for action
against these people. I have to move to strike things
that are not properly brought before the court. Even if
you were to pretend that all the facts as he presents them
are true, he still does not have a case.”
Cochise County Sheriff Larry Dever and County Attorney
Ed Rheinheimer did not respond to calls for comment on the
lawsuit.
Liz Barker, public information officer for CPS, said
she could not comment on the pending litigation. However,
she answered questions about procedure and policy of CPS.
She said when someone calls the statewide hotline phone
number, a series of questions is asked. If the answers
meet the criteria, a report is forwarded to the proper
district office, and staff proceed to investigate.
Barker confirmed that a person’s name remains on file
with CPS even if allegations have not been substantiated.
If the case is substantiated and a conviction obtained,
the name is added to the statewide registry of sex
offenders by the department of public safety.
One other irregularity, as Nord sees it, is a provision
that provides a monetary incentive to CPS staff to
investigate cases. If six cases of abuse or neglect are
investigated per month, the employee receives 10 percent
of the monthly salary.
Barker confirmed that case workers are paid “a
stipend” on the number of cases they investigate. The
sum is paid whether the investigations pan out or not.
That makes Nord wonder if such financial gains are
ethical and if that policy is part of the problem.
“Was I investigated to make more money? Who thought
of this stipend?” he asked. “All I’m trying to do
is clear my name. I had a background check run on myself
and it came back clean,” he added. “But CPS has my
name in a file somewhere, unsubstantiated or not.”
Nord, who claims he is still distressed over the
incident, waits for the lawsuit to be heard. “Can you
imagine waking up one day to find you’re being looked at
as a child molester? And I’m just supposed to take that
and roll over and play dead? I don’t think so.”
REPORTER Shar Porier can be reached at 515-4692 or by
e-mail at shar.porier@bisbeereview.net.
Drugging Video
March 11, 2007
A video recently circulated on the internet, The Drugging of our
Children, produced by Gary Null, deals with the
enormous quantity of drugs given to school children,
including the role of child protectors as prescription
enforcers. Its 103 minutes are of particular interest
to viewers knowledgeable about biology and pharmacology.
Student Gets Real Sex Ed
March 10, 2007
When Nelson A Boylen Collegiate Institute needed a family
studies teacher, they hired the best — a qualified
teacher with experience as a children's aid worker. She
taught her students so well that she will soon give birth to
one of their children.
expand
collapse
Teacher accused of sex with student
Paola Queen, a teacher at Nelson A. Boylen Collegiate
Institute, has been charged with sexual exploitation
after police received a tip about an alleged
inappropriate relationship.
|
Woman is pregnant after alleged
relationship and teen has left high school, police say
March 10, 2007, Betsy Powell Kristin Rushowy, Staff
Reporters
She was a child protection worker who taught family
studies and now she's a high school teacher accused of
having sex with one of her teenage students.
Toronto police have charged Paola Queen, a 35-year-old
teacher at Nelson A. Boylen Collegiate Institute, with
one count of sexual exploitation after they received a
Crime Stoppers tip earlier this month about an alleged
inappropriate relationship between a high school teacher
and a student.
She is pregnant and is at a "substantial stage" into
the nine-month term, Det. Peter Duncan said yesterday.
The student, who has left the north Toronto school on
Falstaff Ave. near Jane St., is believed to be 17 and
cannot be identified by law.
"This was a very good student, someone who has since
left school" and the reasons, while not conclusively
known, are "directly related to that pregnancy," Duncan
said.
Police allege Queen began a romantic and sexual
relationship with the teen not long after she started
teaching at the school in September 2005, "one that has
continued, to our knowledge, to the present time," said
Duncan, of 31 Division. Both speak Spanish, a source
said.
A student in Queen's parenting class said she often saw
the teacher and two brothers in a car together. "She
would let them drive," said the 15-year-old who asked not
to be identified.
Queen was obviously pregnant and recently told students
not to give her grief in class because of her condition,
the student said.
Family members on both sides were also aware of the
relationship and the pregnancy, police said.
"From our investigation it appears that both relatives
of the accused lady and the victimized youth knew of this
relationship and had for some time, several months at
least," Duncan said.
Police exercised two search warrants and they found
photographs showing the pair with other family members.
The teacher had been living with the student "for short
periods at least before she was arrested."
Queen was arrested on Tuesday night.
Under the Criminal Code, no one is allowed to have a
sexual relationship with anyone under 18 years old if they
are in a position of trust or authority "and certainly any
teacher would follow under that description," said Duncan.
A young person at that age is "at an obvious stage in
their emotional development" where they would be
vulnerable to "friendly behaviour and given a degree of
affection would fall into a position where they would
develop an emotional attachment with a teacher as somebody
in a position of authority."
While he doesn't now appear to be traumatized, "this
could be a young man who could take years to fully
understand the impact on his life," he said. "I think
this is something, morally, is going to disgust some
people."
Supt. Roy Pilkington, who runs 31 Division, said it's
not uncommon for men in positions of authority to
victimize young females, but added: "It's very rare –
I've been a police officer for some 34 years – and this
is the first case I can recall in Toronto ... where we've
had this reverse situation."
Queen has been released with conditions not to attend
the school in question. She is to appear at in court
April 17. She has no children of her own and is not
currently married but may be separated or divorced.
She is also to have no contact with the youth. Duncan
admitted this could prove to be problematic if he is
indeed the father of the baby. "That's another sad
dimension."
Queen is a former child protection worker with
Toronto's Catholic Children's Aid Society.
The family studies teacher is now on home assignment,
which means she's on leave with pay until the matter has
been resolved in the courts.
"That's normally the case when a teacher has been
charged with a criminal offence," said board counsel Grant
Bowers.
"That's normally their status until the matter has been
disposed of by the courts."
If found guilty, she'll be fired; if she's acquitted
or the charges are withdrawn, the board will still conduct
its own investigation before deciding if she's allowed to
return to work, added Bowers.
In a letter sent home with students yesterday,
principal Linda Curtis said it's alleged that Queen began
an inappropriate relationship "soon after she started as a
teacher" at the school in September 2005.
Queen became a teacher in June 2005 after obtaining a
bachelor's degree in education from the Ontario Institute
for Studies in Education at the University of Toronto.
According to the Ontario College of Teachers, her
qualifications are in the areas of family studies,
individual and society, and visual arts.
She also has two undergraduate degrees – in arts and
social work – from York University, dating back to 1995.
The Toronto District School Board first heard of the
allegations from police, Bowers said. He could not say if
the school had previously received any complaints about
Queen.
The student is not currently attending Nelson A.
Boylen, although sources said he has not been transferred
to another school.
Even though the charges were laid just days before
March Break, the Toronto board has arranged for
counselling during the holidays should students or staff
request it. A meeting will be scheduled following the
break for parents to air any concerns or to seek advice on
how to discuss the issue at home.
"Our primary goal is to make sure that the students
aren't upset, and to provide any counselling that students
may need," said Bowers. "When a person in authority in a
school community is charged with anything, it can cause
ripples in the school community."
Bowers said the Toronto board has one of the toughest
policies regarding relationships. No employee – teacher
or any other staff member – is allowed to have sexual
relations with a student.
"Any teacher or other employee found guilty (by the
courts), or found by us on the balance of probability to
have abused a child in any way, is terminated
immediately," he said.
"If these allegations are true, and that's a big if,
it's extremely regretful and another example of how we
have to be vigilant and protect our kids."
The Ontario College of Teachers, the profession's
governing body, says if the board alters Queen's terms of
employment "if it restricts her teaching duties or
terminates her, they must let us know," said
communications officer Brian Jamieson.
After receiving the complaint in writing, the college
will investigate, and information would be forwarded to an
investigation committee to decide if an official
disciplinary hearing is warranted. The college's
investigation is separate from that of the police.
In cases where teachers are found guilty of
professional misconduct for having sexual relations with
students, they stand to lose their licence – and, if
that happens, it's almost always permanent, said Jamieson.
Bowers said he will notify the college on Monday.
When asked if the boy's family could sue the board,
Bowers said that Canada is "rather unique because since
the year 2000, the Supreme Court has held school boards
and other institutions vicariously liable" for the
inappropriate actions of teachers and other caregivers of
children.
In Ontario Goverment Everything is
Secret
March 9, 2007
An article by James
Wallace of Osprey Media displays the kind of
investigative journalism normally only seen in the American
press. Ontario's government agencies at all levels deny
requests for information from the public, even routine
requests. Freedom of information requests are stymied with
legal exceptions. The experience of Dufferin VOCA is
similar. Inquiries are commonly met with "that's
confidential". In the case of a request to a children's aid
society, they say nothing, or answer with "we don't supply
that information".
Best Kid Culled
March 8, 2007
Another personal story found on the internet. It is
another "Sophie's Choice" scenario, in which CAS lets mom
and dad keep two kids, they want the other to place with
grandma.
expand
collapse
March 07 (2007)
Bitten By The Scorpion
I have been bitten by the scorpion!
The scorpion being the Children's Aid Society. They
have been involved in my family's life for seven and a
half years, and they sting is still just as painful. They
have been trying to take our son away since he was six
months old, and just couldn't seem to do it. But now they
just may have found a way to keep him away from us
forever. With the help of my "loving" mother of course.
They will allow us to have our daughters but not our son,
and for th life of us all, no one can figure out why.
Especially since they think we're good enough parents to
our daughters that it is safe for them to close their
file. But yet they would rather have my mother gain full
custody of our son. It really doesn't make much sence.
My husband has been reduced to supervised access and now
must see his son under the close scrutiny of the CAS.
That is completely unjustifiable. But what makes it worse
is that he is only allowed to have 2 hours a week. Worse
still is now they are trying to make things even more
difficult for husband by making him sign his life away in
paper work before he caneven get to see his son, and if he
were to not follow any of the supposed rules for
thereputic access, his visits will cease and desist
effective immediately. But yet when he was having visits
before he didn't have to sign a thing and the so called
rules were not nearly as overbearing. The CAS is doing
everything in their power to make excuses as to why my
husband should be refused his access and they are stalling
so that my mother can gain custody of our son.
All of this is because my mother wanted a little boy
and she got me instead. And I got to have the little boy
that she has always wanted with a family that she has
hated for the past twenty-seven years....
In the end it isn't really about a child's wellbing
it's about money and power over the less fortunate. Greed
is a very powerful thing...I just hope that my son and two
daughters can survive the backlash.
We'll just see how much the scorpion will sting when
it's under the heel of my boot!!!
Author's profile:
| Display name: |
Crimson |
| Nickname: |
Crimson_Sorrow_Forever |
| Gender: |
Female |
| Age: |
27 |
| Occupation: |
CSR |
| Interests: |
I love Anne RIce novels and Stephen King. I like
all kinds of music. I love to sing dance
write |
| More about me: |
I'm a mother of three. I'm a student I work I
have a loving husband I'm wiccan I'm aspiring to
be an author and a Forensic Pathologst I also tend
to be a little over dramatic sometimes ob kb I'm
turning into a pumpkin Blessed Be on Thy Journey!
In Love and Light let Trust and hope be with
Thee! |
| Name: |
April Willison |
| Home address: |
Canada |
| Marital status: |
In a relationship |
Apprenticeship for Crime
March 7, 2007
A report acquired by the CBC says that Ontario's
children's aid societies act as apprenticeship programs for
criminal behavior. No one will dare suggest correcting the
problem by leaving children with mom and dad. Instead, we
can soon expect calls for more money for CAS to improve
group homes.
expand
collapse
Kids see group homes as 'gateways to
jail': child advocate
Last Updated: Wednesday, March 7, 2007 | 7:46 AM
ET
CBC News
Almost half of Ontario's young offenders in detention
for minor crimes came through the child welfare system, a
report from the Office of Child and Family Service
Advocacy shows.
The trend is a concern for child advocates across the
country and Ontario Child Advocate Judy Finlay said many
of the province's young people are beginning to think of
group homes as "gateways to jail."
"We're taking them out of very difficult family
circumstances, bringing them into state care and then
we're charging them for their behaviour. It's very
concerning to me," Finlay said.
The report, which was obtained by CBC News, lays much
of the blame on group homes that rely too heavily on
police to resolve problems that could be handled by staff.
Kids have been charged for everything from refusing to
read a book or hitting someone with a tea towel, Finlay
said.
One group home in Ontario called police 400 times in a
single year.
Ontario is not the only province that needs to fix the
system, the report says. A sampling of facilities across
Canada found that 57 per cent of young offenders had a
connection to the child welfare system, the report said.
In British Columbia, a recent study put that number at 73
per cent.
While some teens acknowledge the more serious charges
may be warranted, they complain that too often, staff lack
the training to deal with troubled kids and resort to
calling police.
One teen, who can't be named under federal law, said
workers would often provoke him. After he was charged,
group home workers had an easy way to threaten him by
suggesting a breach of his bail or probation conditions
would mean a return to a young offenders facility.
"They threaten you and say you better read that book or
you're going back to jail. Come on, what kind of system
is this?" the teen said.
Finlay is calling on the province to collect data on
police calls from group homes and the charges that result.
She also wants to see a mental health worker attached to
each group home and higher standards for an industry that
costs taxpayers more than $200 million a year.
Addendum: Here is the start of a
comment on this subject by Carolyn Buck, Executive Director
of Toronto Children's Aid:
The most recent aggregate provincial data shows that
15% of Crown wards under CAS’ care in Ontario were
charged under the Young Offender Act, now the Youth
Criminal Justice Act. This is not the overwhelming
majority as some critics report.
Young people come to us with an array of difficult
experiences. The scars left by the trauma of abuse go
well beyond skin deep and unspeakable acts leave indelible
impressions at the most vulnerable time in human
development.
This drivel requires us to go back to elementary
arithmetic. Judy Finlay divided the number of young
offenders with CAS cases by the number of young offenders
(almost 50%), Carolyn Buck divided it by the number of crown
wards (15%). Of course the results are different. You are
not lying, Mrs Buck, you are just trying to fool us.
The second paragraph goes on to blame the failings of
children in care on the parents they were taken from. If
that is so, why is the death rate in foster care five times
as high as parental care? The most common cause of foster
death for young children is "battered". How do parents
batter their kids in far-away foster homes? There are
indeed unspeakable acts that leave indelible impressions on
children, but they come from the child protection system
itself.
Fredrickson Appeal
March 5, 2007
Rick Fredrickson, deprived of his child by a
Saskatchewan court, has filed an appeal.
The text of the appeal is
online.
CAS Harasses F4J Member
March 5, 2007
Fathers-4-Justice has had success in drawing press
attention to the injustices of family court, and
consequently its members come under intense scrutiny from
agenicies with police power. This press release from Jeremy
Swanson gives more on the soldier, Ken Sandall, harassed by
children's aid.
expand
collapse
CAS INVESTIGATES FORMER OTTAWA F4J COORDINATOR
In November 2006, the Ottawa office of the Children's
Aid Society (CAS) investigated the former Ottawa
Fathers-4-Justice (F4J) Coordinator for being a member of
that group. According to Ken Sandall and another source
who was interview by CAS, questions of Mr. Sandall's F4J
membership and activities were posed. An official CAS
document obtained clearly states that CAS had unverified
child protection concerns but pursued the investigation of
Mr. Sandall regardless.
While earlier acting in the position as Ottawa-area F4J
Coordinator, Mr. Sandall received emails from the CAS
making inquiries and demanding information about local F4J
policies and activities. When Mr. Sandall did not
comply, a damaging and defamatory child protection
investigation was launched against Mr. Sandall.
According to CAS, they received a mysterious, anonymous
complaint-which could not be verified-accusing Mr.
Sandall of many false allegations. However, according to
Mr. Sandall, CAS' investigation went far beyond the
issues and indications provided by this 'phantom' email
from an un-named source. The resulting CAS
interrogative-style interview of Mr. Sandall was focused
on his F4J membership and allegations that the CAS
investigator later admitted were not part of that
'phantom' email or any of the allegations contained
therein
Mr. Sandall's activities with F4J were limited at the
time of his service due to the fact that he is a current
serving member of the Canadian Forces. Mr. Sandall
supported F4J in a supportive, organizational and
administrative capacity. However, after three short
months, he was forced to resign as the F4J Ottawa
Coordinator for family reasons. Mr. Sandall states that
he was not bullied into leaving the F4J position, as the
decision was clearly family-orientated. He still
maintains his basic membership in F4J and other Fathers
and Family Rights groups.
Questioned Saturday Mr Sandall ventured "Is
participation in F4J or any other father's rights groups
illegal ? Does being a father's rights supporter
constitute a danger to children? CAS seems to think so "
he said.
Mr. Sandall tried to directly address the CAS
investigation from the local CAS Ottawa office up to the
CAS' provincial office in Toronto. He received no replies
to phone calls and emails and the official reaction
appears to ignore all attempts at communication in this
matter. Mr. Sandall has launched a complaint to CAS, as
well as his Member of Parliament and the Office of the
Ombudsman of Ontario.
"I fear that, CAS will attempt to 'find' and launch
another allegation against me in response to my complaint
and attempt at redress against them " said Mr Sandall.
-30-
| Contact: |
| Jeremy Swanson |
(613) 237-1320 ext 2438 |
| Ken Sandall |
(613) 249-9470
cell (613) 794-7435 |
United Way Supports CAS
March 4, 2007
When you give a donation to the friendly folks who
collect for the United Way, you are supporting the same
agency that separates parents and children by force of arms.
Here the United Way gives $198,990 to the Mutual Aid Program
for Parents, operated through the Children's Aid Society.
expand
collapse
United Way agencies get boost
By JENNIFER O'BRIEN, SUN MEDIA
[ Paragraphs not relating to Children's Aid
omitted. ]
Yesterday, dozens of community agencies found out
how much money they'll get this year from the United
Way of London and Middlesex as it released allocations
from its record $6.6-million fundraising campaign last
year.
Overall, United Way funding to member agencies will
rise to just more than $5 million this year, up from
$4.4 million last year.
Also, spending on United Way community services and
special programs will rise to nearly $1.63 million
from $1.4 million last year.
Yesterday's funding allocations lit up the office
for United Way staff, said Helen Connell, the local
chapter's executive director.
"There was a feeling of euphoria here today," she
said of the office at 409 King St.
"All day long, people have been coming in to find
out how much they are receiving . . . We get to see
the faces of the agencies and how appreciative they
are.
"It really feels good."
The Mutual Aid Program for Parents, operated
through the Children's Aid Society received a $55,000
boost, bringing its funding to $199,000 to support a
program that helps Spanish-speaking parents.
---
FUNDING ALLOCATIONS
- Across Languages, $32,000
- Big Brothers, $172,300
- Big Sisters, $211,951
- Boys' & Girls' Club, $421,000
- Canadian Hearing Society, $75,900
- Canadian Mental Health Association, $127,703
- CNIB, $210,670
- Changing Ways, $170,000
- Community Living London, $117,051
- Crouch Resource Centre, $109,480
- Epilepsy Support Centre, $100,000.
- Family Service Thames Valley, $401,626
- Girl Guides, $46,000
- Glen Cairn Community Resource Centre, $159,000
- Horton Street Seniors Centre, $70,650
- Hospice of London, $126,500
- John Howard Society, $318,654
- Learning Disabilities Association, $109,000.
- London Coffee House Program, $128,600
- London & District Distress Centre, $134,493
- London Intercommunity Health Centre, $78,655.
- London Interfaith Counselling Centre, $85,325.
- London Occupational Safety & Health, $90,866
- London Unemployment Health Centre, $153,855
- LUSO, $120,796
- Meals on Wheels, $79,000
- Mutual Aid Program for Parents, $198,990
- N'Amerind, $61,233
- Ontario March of Dimes, $94,785
- SARI, $35,500
- Scouts, $42,500
- Sexual Assault Centre, $60,855
- South London Neighbourhood Resource Centre, $104,794
- Stevenson Children's Camp, $93,730
- Next Wave Strathroy Youth Centre, $124,000
- Women's Rural Resource Centre, $58,013.
- London Y, $220,000
- Youth Action Centre, $66,500
VandenElsen Back in Jail
March 2, 2007
Carline VandenElsen, convicted in the Halifax standoff
when police seized her baby in 2004, has been on a temporary
pass helping at a church. At her parole hearing,
she was sent back to jail.
Legal Whistleblower
March 2, 2007
Canada Court Watch has been approached by a whistleblower
lawyer who wants to expose the corruption in family
courts.
expand
collapse
Lawyer calls for judicial inquiry into
dysfunctional family court system!
(March 2, 2007) - A long standing member of the Law
Society of Upper Canada contacted Court Watch recently and
stated that there is an urgent need for a full judicial
and/or Parliamentary inquiry into what this experienced
Law Society member believes is corruption and incompetence
within the family court system in Ontario. This lawyer
says that the current family court system is destroying
children and families and bleeding them dry of their
financial resources. This unnamed source has offered
Court Watch the opportunity to review documents and other
evidence to support this whistle-blower's allegations
about the system and will go on the public record soon
about his allegations. This lawyer has said, that in the
name of justice, the truth about the family court system
in Ontario must be made known to the people of Ontario and
that the family court system must be cleaned up from top
to bottom as it is bringing scorn and disrespect to the
entire legal profession and to those remaining lawyers in
other sectors of the law who still believe that it is
their duty to stand up to vigorously defend the principles
of truth and justice.
Mom and Daughter Jailed
March 2, 2007
A quip attributed to Mark Twain says: “It's no wonder
that truth is stranger than fiction. Fiction has to make
sense.”
In this item, a mother who wants to be with her daughter,
and a daughter who wants to be with her mother are both in
jail to keep them separated. Since it is truth, it doesn't
have to make sense.
expand
collapse
Originally published February 28, 2007
Amber Alert canceled — Missing girl OK,
mom arrested
By Lisa Roose-Church, DAILY PRESS & ARGUS
Submitted photo
Christina Renaud, the Howell-area girl who was the
subject of an Amber Alert, turned up unharmed Tuesday
at the Royal Oak Police Department. The girl's
mother, who is not her legal guardian, is in custody
on parental kidnapping charges.
|
The Livingston County Sheriff's Department said early
Wednesday that the Howell-area girl who was the subject of
an Amber Alert the prior day had turned up at a police
station unharmed.
Meanwhile, the girl’s mother, who is not her legal
guardian, was being held at the Livingston County Jail for
allegedly kidnapping her.
The girl — Christina Renaud, 16, of Oceola Township
— turned up OK at the Royal Oak Police Department on
Tuesday, the same day authorities in that community had
taken her mother, Debbie Renaud, into custody, the
Sheriff's Department said. Debbie Renaud lives in Royal
Oak.
Police say Debbie Renaud requested visitation with her
daughter last week and was to return the teen to her legal
guardian Sunday. But the teen didn't turn up or contact
her guardian as planned, and the Livingston County
prosecutor’s office on Tuesday authorized an arrest
warrant against Debbie Renaud for parental kidnapping.
Also, police issued an Amber Alert for Christina Renaud on
Tuesday.
Royal Oak police arrested the mother later in the day.
Christina Renaud was in protective custody with the
Sheriff’s Department this morning.
Sheriff's Detective Marc King is still investigating
the circumstances surrounding the teen's disappearance.
Contact Daily Press & Argus reporter Lisa
Roose-Church at (517) 552-2846 or at lrchurch@gannett.com.
Adoptions Don't Work
March 2, 2007
When an adoption is finalized, most jurisdictions
issue a phony birth certificate to the adoptee, listing
the adoptive parents as mother and father. These birth
certificates are useless when it comes to protecting the
child from inherited genetic diseases. Another problem
is that the phony birth certificates are not recognized
for citizenship purposes, allowing an adult to
unexpectedly become an illegal alien in his own country
— we reported on the case of Ruth Shaw. Here is a
third problem — inheritance. Olive Watson was
the daughter of IBM magnate Thomas J Watson Jr
(1914-1993). To ensure her lesbian lover Patricia Spado
shared in her inheritance she adopted Spado as her
daughter in 1991. The death of Watson's wife in 2004
activated a provision in the will dividing his estate
among his grandchildren. The Watson family does not
want Spado to get a share, and is challenging the
adoption.
So adopted children can be cut out of their health,
citizenship and inheritance. Once adopted children
reach the age of majority, they are in practice orphans
again.
expand
collapse
IBM heirs battle 'my mother is my
girlfriend' cash claim
Big Blues see red over pink adoption
By Chris Williams
Published Thursday 1st March 2007 00:54 GMT
A lesbian woman who had a long term relationship with
one of the daughters of IBM president Thomas J. Watson Jr
is fighting for her right to a share of his legacy.
Patricia Spado lived with Olive Watson for more than 10
years until they separated in 1992. Watson adopted Spado
under Maine law in 1991. At 44 years old, Spado was one
year her senior.
The unusual arrangement was designed to circumvent
anti-gay marriage laws and allow Spado to become a legal
heir to the trust fund Thomas Watson Jr set up for his
grandkiddies, bringing the total number of beneficiaries
to 19.
When the couple separated, Olive Watson signed an
agreement with her ex stating: "I have not and that I
shall at no time initiate any action to revoke or annul my
adoption of you."
However, Thomas J. Watson's 18 grandchildren are
arguing that the fund, which was opened on his death in
1993, was aimed at blood relatives and that he had no
knowledge of the adoption.
Fund chief Thomas J. Watson III successfully
challenged the legality of the adoption in Connecticut,
where his father died. Spado is appealing that decision,
and is fighting another attempt by the trust to have the
adoption annulled in Maine.
If Spado is denied the millions, she could do worse
than get a job at IBM, which earlier this year topped a poll of the most fabulous places for gay
people to work. ®
US Jails Canadian Boy
March 1, 2007
A Canadian boy, and nearly 200 other children, are in
jail in Texas. In this case, the pretext is immigration.
When children really need help, there are no child
protectors in sight.
expand
collapse
Truthdig
We’ll Lock Up Your Tired, Your Poor,
Your Huddled Masses Yearning to Breathe Free
Posted on Feb 27, 2007
By Amy Goodman
“I want to be free. I want to go outside, and I want
to go to school,” pleaded a 9-year-old boy, on the phone
from prison. This prison wasn’t in some far-off
country, some dictatorship where one would expect children
to be locked up. He is imprisoned in the United States.
The boy, Kevin, is imprisoned in Taylor, Texas, at the
T. Don Hutto Residential Facility. His parents are also
locked up there. The tale of how this family became
imprisoned is just one example of how broken our
immigration policies are in this country. It is a tale of
children left behind, of family values locked up, of your
tax dollars at work.
The parents are Iranian and spent 10 years in Canada
seeking asylum. Kevin, their son, was born in Canada
during that time. Their request for asylum was eventually
denied, and they were deported back to Iran. Majid, the
father, said he and his wife were jailed and tortured
there. They soon fled to Turkey and bought Greek
passports. They hoped to reapply for asylum in Canada,
armed with proof of the torture they suffered in Iran.
On a plane back to Canada, a fellow passenger suffered
a heart attack, requiring an unscheduled landing in Puerto
Rico. Although they never had any intention of entering
the U.S., because the plane touched down here, their
passports were questioned and they were detained. The
family was shipped off to Hutto. They have been there for
more than three weeks.
Immigration detention places the family in a legal
limbo that could leave them imprisoned indefinitely,
perhaps only to be deported back to more torture in Iran.
This shameful practice of locking up children is bad
enough. What’s worse is that it is being done for
profit, by the Corrections Corp. of America. CCA is the
largest publicly traded private prison operator in the
U.S. CCA has close to 70 facilities scattered across the
country, recent earnings of $1.33 billion and a gain in
its stock-share price of 85 percent in the past year.
Industry analysts gush at the profit potential promised by
private prisons. Their commodity: human beings.
A recent report issued jointly by two nonprofit
agencies—the Women’s Commission for Refugee Women and
Children and the Lutheran Immigration and Refugee
Service—titled “Locking Up Family Values: The
Detention of Immigrant Families,” paints a grim picture
of the conditions these families endure. While in 2005
Congress directed the Department of Homeland Security and
Immigration and Customs Enforcement to detain families in
“non-penal, homelike environments,” the report details
how prisonlike the Hutto facility is. While ICE announced
Hutto as a new facility, it was formerly a prison.
Children as young as 6 are separated from their
parents, kept in prison cells with heavy steel doors
equipped with a sensitive laser alarm system. The
children wear prison uniforms. They get one hour of
school per day and one hour of recreation. All non-lawyer
visits are “non-contact,” through a Plexiglas window
speaking over a phone, to obviate the “necessity” of a
full-body cavity search after each visit. Yet the
chairman of the CCA board of directors, William Andrews,
begs to differ: “The reports come from special-interest
groups that are attempting to do away with privatization
and the whole immigration situation. ... The family
facility, particularly, at T. Don Hutto is almost like a
home.” Recent reports put the total number of children
at Hutto at between 170 and 200.
Close to a year after massive pro-immigrant marches
occurred in every major U.S. city, immigration policy
remains broken, with sensational crackdowns on
undocumented workers, a planned multibillion-dollar wall
along the U.S.-Mexico border and more than 26,000
immigrants in prison.
CCA stock is up but the spirits of 9-year-old Kevin are
down as he languishes in his federally funded private
prison cell. He wants to go home to Canada, where he was
born. U.S. immigration officials now hold his fate and
that of his parents: deportation to possible torture in
Iran, or political asylum and a possible return to Canada.
With a Congress obsessed with nonbinding resolutions and
the Bush administration that brought you Abu Ghraib and
the Maher Arar deportation scandal, the prospects for
Kevin and his parents are grim at best.
Amy Goodman is host of “Democracy Now!,” a daily
international TV/radio news hour airing on 500 stations in
North America.
Addendum: Alex Jones calls this
a concentration camp, since it holds people not for
wrongdoing, but for being a member of a group.
Addendum: The boy Kevin and his
family were returned to Canada on March 21. The camp
remains in operation.
expand
collapse
Canadian boy, parents arrive in Toronto
after Texas prison stay
Last Updated: Thursday, March 22, 2007 | 7:41 AM ET,
CBC News
A nine-year-old Canadian boy and his Iranian parents
arrived safely in Toronto on Wednesday night after being
held for six weeks in a Texas detention centre.
"Thank you for everybody who helped us," Kevin
Yourdkhani said, clutching his bags at Toronto's Pearson
International Airport.
Masomeh Alibegi holds up immigration papers as she
walks with nine-year-old son Kevin Yourdkhani and his
father Majid after arriving at a Toronto airport on
Wednesday.Masomeh Alibegi holds up immigration papers
as she walks with nine-year-old son Kevin Yourdkhani
and his father Majid after arriving at a Toronto
airport on Wednesday. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)
|
Kevin and his parents, Majid Yourdkhani and Masomeh
Alibegi, flew into the airport from Houston, landing in
Toronto at about 5:45 p.m. ET. The couple had tears in
their eyes after leaving the plane.
The family was allowed to come to Canada after
Immigration and Citizenship Minister Diane Finley agreed
to give them temporary residency permits two weeks ago.
The permits arrived in Texas on Monday.
Finley said she granted the permits in the best
interest of the boy. The family is now trying to claim
refugee status.
Kevin's parents arrived in Canada 10 years ago seeking
asylum, but were unsuccessful and deported to Iran in
December 2005. Kevin was born when they lived in Canada.
The parents said they faced torture in Iran and made
another attempt to seek refuge in Canada with the use of
stolen Greek passports.
But on a flight to Toronto from Guyana on Feb. 4, a
passenger suffered a heart attack and died, resulting in
the plane being diverted to Puerto Rico.
U.S. officials discovered their false documents and
detained them for five days before sending them to the T.
Don Hutto detention centre near Austin, Texas. The
converted medium-security prison has been condemned by
human rights groups and is the subject of a lawsuit by the
American Civil Liberties Union.
The family said living in the centre was awful.
"It was miserable condition they had over there," Majid
Yourdkhani said, standing by his wife as he spoke to
reporters at the Toronto airport.
"There are almost 200 children that live there in very
bad conditions. Now most of the children there have
chicken pox, eye infections, flu."
His wife said the family is relieved to be back in
Canada, and young Kevin said he can now resume his life in
Toronto.
"I will go back to my school, to my teachers," the boy
said.
Children Snatched
February 28, 2007
The mother identified only by her maiden name Lisa Sweet has lost her children
again. Below are two posts by the mother to Sarnia's
Smoking Gun about yesterday's apprehension.
expand
collapse
CAS took the kids at 12.30 pm today, based on saying I
missed appointments. I have the letters from both the
dentist and the doctor saying that I haven't missed any
appointments all. Then they say my kids are dirty, the
school called yet they do not call on the girl who
threatens to kill her kids. The principal just doesn't
like me. My kids are never dirty. It's that the worker
cannot get my husband on drugs or anything like that.
They want six months and that stupid court clinic
assesment thingy.
My mother-in-law wants to sue them now as we have done
everything that they want us to do.
On Friday my oldest daughter threw a fit at school, so
they called CAS on me saying they are concerned.
I'm not sure how I'm going to fight it this time as no
matter what I do nothing is good enough for that
worker.
I want a worker change but they refuse, she is way to
biased against me to begin with.
They let my ex friend threaten her kids with I'm gonna
shoot you you stupid ..... she locked him in his room
when he got suspended from last Thursday until today. Yet
CAS turns their heads because her kids are 4 and 5 and
don't know how to talk yet.
I want to take it to the media but im not sure how
to.
Lisa
Thanks bizzi, I'm so heartbroken right now, had to
watch them take my four-year-old away crying. As soon as
she saw the police outside and the worker she started
shaking and freaking out. I don't blame her.
I asked to see the papers, they had they refused to let
us see them. I asked for the kids to go to family and
they started asking if the kids knew them, how old they
were if they were married, etc, then told me that they
haven't even called but I know they did.
My mother-in-law wants to sue them, but I told her I
wouldn't even know where to start with that. The worker
has told me she will get my kids no matter what, anyway
they split them up again.
They try to tell me no money is involved, yeah right,
I'm one of the bought children I know better than that.
They want six months, I know if I give it to them I've
definitly lost for sure. It all stemmed with the
eight-year-old throwing tantrums at school which only
seems to happen after the worker on an almost daily basis
harassess them at school.
She, the worker, followed me home from school on
Friday, we just got in the door not even 5 min before she
got here, so there were coats on the floor and she didn't
like that and there was water and mud from the kids boots
that I was cleaning up as she came in the door. Doesn't
seem to get this is natural for this time of year.
I will submit pics to the courts as they say my kids
are always dirty, I'm one of those that loves lots of
pictures so I take them at random. Guess its a good thing
I do that as the kids are not dirty in one of them neither
is my house.
The police looked at the worker kind of funny when I
asked her why someone across the street was allowed to say
she was going to shoot her four-year-old and continually
belittles him and screams at him. No answer from her, but
I know why, its because that girls kids at four and five
don't even have the language skills of a two-year-old so
they don't want to adopt them as people here only want
good kids not from drug addicted families.
Foster Care Damages Kids
February 27, 2007
On February 12 the Child Welfare League of America
(CWLA), the trade association for the child protection
industry, produced a report showing that about a tenth of
children moved into a foster home will be in a hospital
emergency room in the first three weeks, and that foster
alumni suffer elevated mental problems. Supporters of child
protection cannot deny its conclusions, since it is their
own product. Of course, the report is used to lobby for
even more money, rather than keeping kids out of foster
care. Summary of important
conclusions with links to full report.
Family Under Attack
February 27, 2007
Here is an item found on the internet that will probably
be gone soon, when CAS bullies the parents. Past
indiscretions, real or imagined, cannot be forgiven by
CAS.
expand
collapse
| Name: |
Kimberley |
| Occupation: |
small business owner |
| Age: |
31 |
| Location: |
Ontario |
| Interests: |
I enjoy cooking knitting quilting cross-stitch
baking going for walks going to church riding on
the four wheeler horses dogs and spending time
with family. |
February 23
Hello world!!
Greetings to everyone,
This is the first time I have ever posted on here. So
please bare with me. I'm not quite sure what to say. So
I will give you some info on my myself and my husband.
John and I have been married since September 2006.
Things are going really great he is a wonderful man. We
have a little girl. She was born in June 2006. She isn't
home right now; she was taken by the Children's Aid
Society at birth.
My husband and I have been working very hard to get her
home for the last eight months. You see to make the long
story short; they(CAS) believe that they have just cause
to have her. I made some really bad choices when I was
younger and I lost two girls to them four years ago after
fighting for two and half years. I had to give them up
because I had no other options. So that is just part of
the reason why my new little angel is not home. The other
reason is about as far off course as it could be.
They(CAS) claim to have charges against my husband on an
assault from 1993. The reason I say the charges are
outrageous and do not have any substance is that when the
supposed assault happened he wasn't even in the country.
My husband had left home in 1992 and lived in the states
for one year then moved to Alberta where he stayed for 9
years. He returned in 2001. Nothing was ever said about
charges against him that whole time period. Now that we
have a daughter together they(CAS) seem to think they can
take her because apparently in their eyes people don't
grow up and change.
I am rather upset that they can do this to families.
My husband and I are devoted christians and are no longer
struggling with our past. God gave us our daughter to
raise her ourselves not for the CAS to take.
Well I think that is enough for now. Talk to you all
soon.
Kimberley
Please Don't Feed the Children
February 26, 2007
Child protectors in England have the perfect cure for an
overweight boy — take away his mother! In 2000 child
protectors in New Mexico seized three-year-old Anamarie
Martinez-Regino from her parents for obesity, but gave her
back a few months later after a public outcry. The current
case appears to be an unmarried mother, so the outcome is
unpredictable.
Is it possible the bean-counters have been working
overtime on this? Putting obese children on half-rations,
while collecting full foster care rates from the treasury,
could ratchet up their profits
reimbursement.
expand
collapse
Last Updated: Tuesday, 27 February 2007, 04:06 GMT
Fourteen stone child 'risks care'
Connor prefers to eat processed foods
|
An eight-year-old boy who weighs over 14
stone (89kg) may be taken into care by a local
authority.
Connor McCreaddie, from Wallsend, North Tyneside, has
lost a stone and a half in two months, but still prefers
processed food to fruit and vegetables.
His mother, Nicola McKeown, has been called to a child
protection conference with the local authority on
Tuesday.
Family support may be offered, but the last resort
would be for North Tyneside officials to place Connor into
care.
Connor's pre-Christmas weight of 15 stones and eight
pounds (98.8kg) is four times the weight of a healthy
child of his age.
He has lost weight after beginning an intensive
exercise regime and introducing some healthy food into his
diet.
The eight-year-old does have a bike and a trampoline
which he uses, but he has to stop after around 10 minutes
because he becomes out of breath and can vomit.
He has difficulty dressing and washing himself, misses
school regularly because of poor health and is a target
for bullies.
Confident
Ms McKeown, 35, told the BBC: "Connor had a mouthful
of apple once and he didn't like it.
"He refuses to eat fruit, vegetables and salads - he
has processed foods.
"When Connor won't eat anything else, I've got to give
him the foods he likes.
"I can't starve him.
"But I'm confident I can get his weight down with a bit
of help."
Ms McKeown denied she is neglecting her son, and said
he would be "skinny" if she had been.
She said she had seen doctors, but no-one had actually
stepped in to offer her help.
She said that taking Connor into care would be
"disastrous".
His story was due to be featured in ITV's Tonight With
Trevor McDonald, which followed Connor and his mother for
a month.
Child's interests 'paramount'
Dr Colin Waine, chairman of the National Obesity Forum,
said that removing a child from their family could be
justified.
"The long-term impacts of this child's gross obesity
are frightening.
"He has great risk of diabetes and coronary illness.
"His life expectancy is severely prejudiced. So action
is required if his health is to be safeguarded."
A spokeswoman for North Tyneside Council and North
Tyneside Primary Care Trust, said: "We share the concerns
over the child's health and well-being.
"We have been working with the family over a prolonged
period of time and will continue to do so.
"The child's interests are paramount."
Single Mom Harassed
February 26, 2007
The San Antonio Texas Express-News has printed a lengthy
story on the Lozano family. Ordinarily, the press only
reports on extraordinary child protection cases, such as
those involving an injured or dead child. This article
deals with the most common kind of child protection
case, the single mom. Details show many common tactics,
such as omitting facts favorable to the family and a
"Sophie's Choice": you get to keep some kids as long as
we get the rest. When the family genuinely needs help
it is denied. A digression shows the habit of the
legislature to respond to all problems in the system by
giving it even more money. Links to San Antonio
Express-News and our local copy.
CPS Comes out Swinging
February 24, 2007
We have previously noted that child protectors harass
nudists, vegetarians, smokers and prostitutes. Here is
another group that must look over their shoulder for big
sister.
expand
collapse
'Wife Swap' appearance sparks child abuse
calls for Iowa family
By Christopher Rocchio, 02/22/2007
An appearance on ABC's Wife Swap reality series almost
found an Iowa couple in hot water for child abuse.
Barb and Mike Haigwood -- a couple who raise organic
food with their two teenage children on a farm near
Massena, IA -- sparked Wife Swap viewers to contact the
Iowa Department of Human Services after an episode
featuring the family aired on Monday, February 19, The Des
Moines Register reported Wednesday.
During the Wife Swap broadcast, the Haigwood children
-- 13-year-old Aleesha and 16-year-old Lee -- said they
don't go to school and Lee's home schooling includes
counting the number of eggs the family's chickens have
produced. Barb, the family's 37-year-old mother, also
explained that she "believes in eating every two to three
hours" -- a belief that causes her to wake the children
for late-night drinkings of a beverage containing kefir, a
yogurt-like product.
Prior to their Wife Swap appearance, Barb had told The
Register that family's decision to eat "nothing but raw
food, including eggs and meat" was part of their way of
dealing with health problems related to Aleesha's
attention deficit disorder.
However The Register reported Iowa state officials do
not consider "an unorthodox diet and messy housekeeping"
to be child abuse, and added the parents have filed the
proper paperwork to home-school their two children. Iowa
Department of Human Services spokesman Roger Munns told
The Register his department "logged a number of calls" to
its child-abuse hotline after the episode aired, and also
received "at least 10 messages emailed to its website" as
well as a fax.
"DHS only investigates child abuse and neglect cases
when there is a credible report that, if proven true,
would amount to abuse. None of these reports rise to that
threshold," Munns told The Register. "People who eat
unusual food and feed it to their children are not
abusive, nor are people whose houses are not tidy."
Steve Pelzer, superintendent of the Cumberland and
Massena school district, said that -- as the law requires
--the Haigwoods have filed paperwork "proving competent
private schooling." Pelzer added a licensed teacher from
the West Des Moines area "monitors the children's
progress."
Bard told The Register on Tuesday that the family could
not comment unless reporters "went through ABC's public
relations department." A spokesman for ABC could not be
reached on Tuesday, according to The Register.
Stop Teen Screen
February 24, 2007
Promoters of a program called TeenScreen want to examine
every American teenager for signs of mental illness. Teens
failing the tests will be referred to a psychiatrist, and
prescribed psychotropic drugs.
You can find an account of the whole process on the
website TeenScreen Truth. An alliance between the psychiatric
profession and the drug industry pushes the drugs and
divides the spoils. Force and deception assist at every
stage. Parents are required to consent, but that consent is
obtained by mailing out a letter. If the parent does not
respond, it is deemed to be consent. The child must sign
another consent form, but instructions tell the clinicians
to treat non-consent as failing the test. After a
prescription is issued the child protection system acts as
enforcers by treating non-compliance with prescriptions as
medical neglect.
The actual questionnaires used are confidential, but
copies have made their way into cyberspace. For
example, here is the self-administered questionnaire used by Columbia
University (pdf). You can find more forms,
including those used to evaluate the results, at Liberty
Coalition. Subjects failing the self-administered
test get another questionnaire administered by a
professional. One of the questions is: "In the last
year, have you used marijuana six or more times?". The
instructions tell the clinician to expect "yes"; a "no"
is an indicator of untruthfulness.
If successful in the US, this program is likely to spread
to Canada. You have an opportunity to help stop this
program in its early stages with an online petition. Many petitions relating to family law
attract dozens or hundreds of signatures, but the TeenScreen
petition is approaching twenty thousand signatures. We hope
to see some Dufferin VOCA readers on the list.
Addendum: In the two days
following this article there was a spurt of signatures on
the petition, including several known Dufferin VOCA
readers.
Bail for ?????
February 24, 2007
A woman without a name accused of killing a child without
a name has been granted bail for reasons that cannot be
published. Earlier this month a blue-ribbon panel was
established to do an investigation that will keep the case
out of the public eye for two years. The extraordinary
cloak of secrecy over this case lends credence to otherwise
unfounded rumors that the accused is well-connected
politically. We had previous reports on
January 28,
January 31,
February 5 and
February 13.
One of the functions of convicting a foster parent for
the death of a ward is to divert attention away from the
failure of the responsible agency. But who can accept an
unnamed person as a scapegoat? This may become an
interesting case.
expand
collapse
Foster mother charged with murder granted
bail
Last Updated: Friday, February 23, 2007 | 4:05 PM MT
CBC News
An Edmonton woman charged with second-degree murder in
the death of her three-year-old foster child has been
granted bail.
After hearing arguments Friday, a Court of Queen's
Bench judge ruled that the 32-year-old woman has to post a
$10,000 cash bond and is forbidden from having any
unsupervised contact with children, including her own two
biological children.
Outside court, the foster mother's lawyer, Brian
Beresh, said the woman was elated to be granted bail.
"This is just the classic case where you would never
expect, given her history, that she would ever be in jail.
This is just unbelievable — she has been shattered by
this experience."
Beresh accused authorities of making a "rush to
judgment" when she was charged.
"We were very disappointed that people did not view
this objectively, collect information objectively. From
my review of what I have seen so far there appears to be
certain individuals or agencies, which appear to be
protecting their own conduct."
The three-year-old boy died in an Edmonton hospital on
Jan. 27 of head injuries after being rushed from his
foster home.
Charges against his foster mother include second-degree
murder, assault causing bodily harm, and child abandonment
or failure to provide the necessities of life.
She can't be named under the Child, Youth and Family
Enhancement Act.
The judge has issued a publication ban on what was said
in court Friday.
Protect Kids from Imagination
February 23, 2007
The Onion lampoons overprotection of children, suggesting
imagination is hazardous. There is a sad record of today's
spoof becoming tomorrow's reality.
expand
collapse
Child-Safety Experts Call For Restrictions
On Childhood Imagination
February 20, 2007 | Issue 43•08
WASHINGTON, DC—The Department of Health and Human
Services issued a series of guidelines Monday designed to
help parents curtail their children's boundless
imaginations, which child-safety advocates say have the
potential to rival motor vehicle accidents and congenital
diseases as a leading cause of disability and death among
youths ages 3 to 14.
Jill Tyn, 4, perilously close to danger.
|
"Defuse the ticking time-bomb known as your child's
imagination before it explodes and destroys her
completely," said child-safety expert Kenneth McMillan,
who advised the HHS in composing the guidelines. "New
data shows a disturbing correlation between serious
accidents and the ability of children to envision a world
full of exciting possibility."
The guidelines, titled "Boundless Imagination,
Boundless Hazards: Ways To Keep Your Kids Safe From A
World Of Wonder," are posted on the HHS website, and will
also be available in brochure form in pediatricians'
offices across the country.
According to McMillan, children can suffer broken
bones, head trauma, and even fatal injuries from
unsupervised exposure to childlike awe. "If your children
are allowed to unlock their imaginations, anything from a
backyard swing set to a child's own bedroom can be
transformed into a dangerous undersea castle or dragon's
lair," McMillan said. "But by encouraging your kids to
think linearly and literally, and constantly reminding
them they can never be anything but human children with no
extraordinary characteristics, you can better ensure that
they will lead prolonged lives."
Although the exact number of child fatalities connected
to an active imagination is unknown, experts say the
danger is very real. According to a 2006 estimate,
children who regularly engage in imagination are 10 times
more likely to suffer injuries such as skinned knees from
mythical quests, or bruises and serious falls from the
peak of Bookcase Mountain.
One of the HHS recommendations emphasizes increased
communication between parents and children about the
truths behind outlandish fantasies. "Speak with your
children about the absolute impossibility of time travel,
magical powers, and animals and toys that talk when adults
are not around," reads one excerpt. "If this fails to
quell their imaginations, encourage them to stare at
household objects and think clearly and objectively about
their actual, physical characteristics."
The HHS also discourages aimless playtime activities
that lack a rigid, repetitive structure: "Opt instead for
safe activities like untying knots, sticking and
unsticking two pieces of Velcro, drawing straight lines of
successively longer lengths, and quietly humming a single
note for two to three hours."
But even these relatively safe activities can become
imaginative, experts warn, without proper precautions.
"Do not let children know that, for example, sailors and
pirates untie knots," McMillan said.
Although no cure has yet been developed for childhood
imagination, preventative measures can deter children from
potentially hazardous bouts of make-believe.
"Many of the suggestions are really quite simple, like
breaking down cardboard boxes or sewing cushions to
couches so they cannot be converted into forts or
playhouses," McMillan said. "Blank pieces of paper, which
can inspire non-reality-based drawings, should be
discarded unless they are used in one of our recommended
diagonal folding and unfolding activities. And all loose
sticks left lying in the yard should be carefully labeled
'Not a Sword.'"
Unfortunately, removing everything from a child's field
of view that could stimulate his active young mind is
extremely time-consuming, and infeasible as a long-term
solution, McMillan acknowledges. "To truly protect your
children, you must go to great lengths to completely
eliminate their curiosity, crush their spirit of
amazement, and eradicate their childlike glee. Watch for
the danger signs: faraway expressions, giggle fits, and a
general air of carefree contentment."
Added McMillan: "Remember, if you see a single sparkle
of excitement in their eyes, you haven't done enough."
Addendum: Here it is in real
life from the publication Archives of Diseases in
Childhood March 2007, a publication of BMJ (British
Medical Journal). Mamas, don't let your boys grow up to be
superheroes.
expand
collapse
Superhero-related injuries in paediatrics:
a case series
Patrick Davies1, Julia Surridge2, Laura Hole3 and Lisa
Munro-Davies3
ABSTRACT
Five cases of serious injuries to children wearing
superhero costumes, involving extreme risk-taking
behaviour, are presented here. Although children have
always displayed behaviour seemingly unwise to the adult
eye, the advent of superhero role models can give
unrealistic expectations to the child, which may lead to
serious injury.
The children we saw have all had to contemplate on
their way to hospital that they do not in fact possess
superpowers. The inbuilt injury protection which some
costumes possess is also discussed.
Dear Abby Criticizes CPS
February 23, 2007
Respect for child protectors has sunk to the level that
the Dear Abby column will now print a letter critical of
CPS. In December, Dear Abby printed an item of the subject
of children driving golf carts, and on February 8 the letter
below was printed in response.
expand
collapse
Dear Abby: A 6-year-old driving a golf cart is child
endangerment, and a social worker has the right to remove
that child to a foster home and ask questions later. The
parents would then be under a microscope.
Because the grandparent knew about the situation and
did not report it to the authorities, the grandparents
would probably not be considered safe guardians for that
child, and the child would be placed with strangers until
the parents finish court-ordered parenting classes.
Foster children are big business. It's a totally
different climate than it was in the days when only
severely neglected and abused children found their way
into foster care.
I speak from 17 years of experience as a foster parent
and 30 years as a psychiatric nurse who has seen what
hoops families must jump through to get their children
back once child protective services is involved.
– Reader in Ferris, Texas
$765,590 for baby-stealers
$0 for mom and dad
February 23, 2007
In another announcement that shows the politicians just
don't get it, MPP David Orazietti and Premier Dalton
McGuinty announce even more money for agencies usurping the
functions of mom and dad.
expand
collapse
SooToday.com
Dalton & Dave shake their moneymakers
By David Helwig, SooToday.com, Thursday, February 22,
2007
NEWS RELEASE
DAVID ORAZIETTI, MPP
*************************
Orazietti announces $765,590 in new funding for
children and youth in Sault Ste. Marie
McGuinty government investment creates jobs and
supports the local economy
Sault Ste. Marie – The McGuinty government is
investing $765,950 in Sault Ste. Marie to help eight
not-for-profit organizations better serve children, youth
and families while strengthening the local economy, David
Orazietti, MPP announced today.
"With this investment, our government is providing
further support for children and youth in Sault Ste.
Marie," said Orazietti. "These additional funds to expand
or upgrade facilities that serve our community's young
people will also help create jobs and boost local economic
development."
Local organizations benefiting from this latest
government investment include:
- Children’s Rehabilitation Centre Algoma, $484,950
- Ontario Early Years Centre, $150,000
- Algoma Family Services, $39,000
- Children’s Aid Society of Algoma, $44,780
- Child Care Algoma, $29,860
- John Howard Society, $7,000
- Northern Youth Services, $7,000
- Operation Springboard, $3,000
Funding for these projects comes from an investment of
more than $37 million by the Ministry of Children and
Youth Services to help targeted service providers across
the province improve or expand more than 900
buildings.
Projects range from general repairs to improve energy
efficiency and better meet safety requirements to major
construction and renovations to existing buildings.
"These investments will not only help to better serve
some of our most vulnerable children, youth and their
families, but they will contribute to economic growth and
opportunities in these communities," said Minister of
Children and Youth Services Mary Anne Chambers.
The ministry's contribution is a key part of the
government’s recently announced $190 million economic
stimulus package aimed at creating the equivalent of 3,000
jobs across the province on top of the 270,000 net new
jobs created since 2003.
"While the economy remains fundamentally strong, it is
important to remember that slower growth has a real impact
on people and communities," said Finance Minister Greg
Sorbara. "Investing in these areas that assist families
and communities now means a more prosperous and
competitive future for Ontario."
*************************
Professional Dissent to Forced Drugging
February 21, 2007
A group of academics with credentials in social work is
opposing an adherence initiative of the National Association
of Social Workers (NASW).
Adherence is a technical term with the medical
definition:
The extent to which the patient continues the
agreed-upon mode of treatment or intervention as
prescribed
In social work, adherence means forcing patients to take
their medicine. At the field level, social workers tell
parents to administer psychotropic drugs to their children,
or lose the children to foster care.
Last October the NASW sent an email
to members asking them to join the initiative (MS Word
format). The dissenting letter is below. In the restrained
tones of academics it exposes the junk science behind the
pushing of psychotropic drugs.
expand
collapse
Open Letter to NASW Regarding "Adherence
Initiative for Schizophrenia" Sponsored by Janssen,
L.P:
Elvira Craig de Silva, DSW, ACSW
President, National Association of Social Workers (NASW)
Elizabeth Clark, PhD, ACSW
Executive Director, NASW, and President, NASW Foundation
On October 6, 2006, the National Association of Social
Workers (NASW) sent to its Specialty Practice Sections on
mental health and private practice an emailed
“Invitation to Join The National Adherence Initiative
for Schizophrenia.” An article in the November issue of
NASW News also announces and describes the initiative (1).
The brief text in the email asked social workers to
consider enrolling “in a nationwide data collection
effort.” It stated: “Partial adherence is a
significant problem in the treatment of schizophrenia …
and can affect up to 75% of patients.” It invited
participants to “identify up to 10 clients with
schizophrenia that you feel are at risk for partial
adherence.”
The last line of the text informed that this initiative
“is sponsored by Janssen, L.P. in partnership with
NASW.” The pharmaceutical company Janssen, a subsidiary
of Johnson & Johnson, markets Risperdal
(risperidone), an antipsychotic drug that grossed $2.3
billion in US sales in 2005 (2). Social workers who
enrolled received a packet from Janssen, with the “study
instrument,” that spoke of nothing but the importance of
drug treatment adherence for schizophrenia.
The undersigned social workers and social work
educators and researchers are, for several reasons,
concerned about the NASW’s active participation in this
pharmaceutical company marketing initiative.
First, now is a time of unprecedented awareness of the
pharmaceutical industry’s stake in framing how distress
and mental disorders are seen and how they are treated
(3). This industry has used every means at its
disposal—including one-to-one enticement of
professionals (4), sponsorship and delivery of continuing
“education” (5), sponsorship of advocacy groups,
ghost-writing of “scientific” articles and
dissemination of unsupported “medication algorithms”
(6), direct-to-consumer advertising, intense legislative
lobbying (7), as well as suppression of research findings,
illegal marketing of psychotropic drugs for off-label
purposes (8), and cash payments to state officials to
include atypical antipsychotics on Medicaid formularies
(9)—to remain the dominant player in health and mental
health. Regardless of evidence of drugs’ efficacy or
safety, the industry’s unrivaled ability to spread money
to influence thinking, practice, and policymaking means
that the mental health system serves the industry, rather
than the opposite.
Second, as non-industry funded studies increasingly
identify the limitations of its products and exaggerated
claims made about them, the industry greatly diversifies
marketing efforts to dilute any impact of bad news on drug
sales. Countless seemingly “independent” professional
and advocacy activities are today carefully orchestrated
and funded by marketing firms to reach specific
prescription goals (8). The stark truth is that no mental
health profession and no professional activity is safe
from drug industry influence. Moreover, mere awareness of
the issue cannot guard against being used as part of the
industry’s marketing efforts. As authors from
psychology have recently recommended, mental health
professions need to build a “firewall” between
marketing and science. (10) Authors from medicine
similarly call for “a strict sequestration of commercial
and scientific activities, and a fundamental internal
reevaluation of the interactions between individual
physicians, professional organizations, and the
industry” (8). Did the NASW consider such warnings, now
so numerous in the literature as to defy counting?
Third, it seems to us that the NASW did not
sufficiently scrutinize an “adherence initiative” in
2006. Treatment compliance is an old issue in
schizophrenia care. Everyone in this field knows that
antipsychotic drugs’ unpleasant effects make them
extremely undesirable to patients. The Janssen initiative
closely follows the government-sponsored CATIE studies’
findings that three quarters of patients on atypical
antipsychotics such as Janssen’s Risperdal—falsely
touted for a decade as vast improvements over older
drugs—stop taking their prescribed medication because of
“inefficacy, intolerable adverse effects, or other
reasons” (11).
The study instrument mailed to social workers consists
of eight “yes/no” questions, each describing a
“deficit” in patients that would put them “at
risk” of “partial adherence.” In our view, no
information not already well known from dozens of previous
studies on adherence to neuroleptic treatment, including
the $45 million CATIE studies on nearly 1,500 patients, is
likely to come from this Janssen-NASW study. The
adherence initiative repeats that “partial adherence”
is a significant problem in the treatment of
schizophrenia—but the more significant problem lies
rather with the drugs’ now well established
ineffectiveness and adverse effects.
Fourth, and more to the point, Janssen’s exclusive
patent to market oral risperidone will expire in 2007, and
the company stands to lose significant revenue as cheaper
generic versions come to market. Janssen is therefore now
emphasizing the long-acting injectable version of
risperidone, which it markets as Risperdal Consta—on
which it still holds patent for several more years (and
which sells for more than the oral version). The history
of antipsychotic drug use shows that one notion, and one
notion only, has ever justified using long acting
injectable antipsychotics: adherence (compliance). In
this light must Janssen’s “adherence initiative” be
more fully appreciated.
Finally, even as social work researchers lead the
questioning of a failed paradigm constraining explanation
and intervention in the lives of persons who experience
psychosis (12), we are mystified that the NASW allies
itself with Big Pharma, rather than lead the unbiased
search for veritable innovations in care. Improvement
rates in schizophrenia, after more than 50 years of drug
treatment, are worse now than they were 80 years ago (13).
Given that mental disorders and psychosis are strongly
correlated with environmental factors such as low
socioeconomic status (14) and childhood trauma (15), the
NASW should formally endorse the preventive research of
social workers that attempts to protect youth from harmful
experiences or to foster healthy lifestyles and
psychological resilience. Rather than lend even more
credence to pharmaceuticals, the NASW should spearhead an
initiative to publicize available psychosocial treatments
that teach coping skills, interpersonal skills, and
independent living skills that allow clients to function
with minimal reliance on costly and potentially harmful
drugs.
The undersigned consider this “adherence
initiative” a campaign directly promoting the drug
treatment of schizophrenia and indirectly promoting
Janssen’s image and products. The “adherence”
sought is that of social workers and other professionals
to a treatment model guided by drugs—Janssen’s drugs.
That this initiative seeks to enroll social workers in a
seeming research effort for the benefit of patient care
simply cannot be taken as its primary purpose. More than
anything, the initiative expresses to outside observers
that yet another professional organization could not
remain independent of the pharmaceutical industry’s
influence.
It is our understanding that Janssen initiated the
contact with the NASW, remunerated the consultant from the
NASW, and made a donation to the NASW Foundation in return
for this collaboration. (No mention of this donation
appears in the NASW News article.) The other organizations
partnering with Janssen in this initiative include the
National Alliance on Mental Illness, the (American)
Psychiatric Nurses Association, and Schizophrenics
Anonymous, all of which benefit from drug company
largesse.
We request, first, that the NASW publicly backtrack on
this initiative; second, that for the sake of
transparency the NASW discloses the amount that Janssen
donated to the NASW Foundation; and third, that the NASW
inform its membership and the broader constituencies it
aims to serve precisely how it intends to protect itself
from other pharmaceutical industry initiatives certain to
follow this most unfortunate precedent.
Signed:
- David Cohen, PhD
Professor, Florida International University
- Stephen E. Wong, Ph.D.
Associate Professor, Florida International University
- Tomi Gomory, PhD
Associate Professor, Florida State University
- Jeffrey Lacasse, PhD Candidate
Visiting Lecturer, Florida State University
- Dennis Saleeby, PhD
Professor Emeritus, University of Kansas
- Stuart A. Kirk, DSW
Professor, University of California, Los Angeles
- John Bola, PhD
Assistant Professor, University of Southern California
- Eileen Gambrill, PhD
Professor, University of California, Berkeley
- Linda Vinton, PhD
Professor, Florida State University
- Scott Ryan, PhD
Associate Professor, Florida State University
- Kia J. Bentley, PhD
Professor, Virginia Commonwealth University
- C. Aaron McNeece, PhD
Dean & Professor, Florida State University
- Wendy Crook, PhD
Associate Professor, Florida State University
- Mark A. Mattaini, DSW
Associate Professor, University of Illinois at Chicago
- Nicholas Mazza, PhD
Professor, Florida State University
- Blace Nalavany, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor, East Carolina University
- Devon Brooks, Ph.D.
Associate Dean for Faculty Affairs and Associate
Professor, University of Southern California
- D. Lynn Jackson, Ph.D.
Director of Field Instruction, University of North
Texas
- Donni P. Whitsett, Ph.D.,
University of Southern California
REFERENCES
1. Pace, P. R. (2006, November). NASW joins
adhere |